Pie Orders
If you would like to place a pie order please call us at 941-955-7771. Cream pies are available all day long, however baked pies must be ordered at least one day in advance. At this time we are only taking pie orders by phone. Thank You
Gift Cards
If you would like to purchase a gift card please call us at 941-955-7771
Welcome to Yoder's
Welcome to Yoder's, a Sarasota tradition since 1975! Since first opening it's doors, Yoder's has been synonymous with Mom's homemade Amish pies and hearty portions of great home cooking served with fast, friendly service in a family atmosphere.
Yoder's Amish Restaurant has been a long time favorite with local residents, voted first place by the People's Choice awards (Sarasota Herald Tribune & Channel 40) for:
* Best Dinner Under $10.00
* Best Amish Restaurant
* Best Homemade Desserts
* Best Key Lime Pie
* Best Carry out
* Best Breakfast
Yoder's continues to be a destination spot for people far and near and continues to serve up the most delicious Amish home cooking experience you've ever tasted. Guaranteed!
