Explore the Village


Homemade Pies

4.95 per slice. À la mode add 2.00.

Our pies are baked fresh FROM SCRATCH every morning.
No meal at Yoder’s is ever complete without a piece of homemade pie.


Cream Pies

Banana Cream
Chocolate Cream
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Coconut Cream

Florida Key Lime
(Traditional in graham crust)
Fresh Strawberry
Homemade Butterscotch  


Peanut Butter Cream
Pineapple Cream
Red Raspberry Cream
Yoder's Key Lime

Baked Pies

Baked Peach 
Black Raspberry 
Blueberry Crumb
Caramel Custard
Chocolate Pecan 

Double Crust Apple
Double Crust Blueberry 
Dutch Apple Crumb
Mincemeat (seasonal) 
Mom’s Egg Custard
Red Raspberry
Southern Pecan
Strawberry Rhubarb
Sugar Free Apple
Sugar Free Blueberry


Cakes and More

Homemade Cheesecake 5.50
Yoder’s Best Chocolate Cake 4.95

Cake of the Day 4.95
Hand-dipped Ice Cream 3.50
with Fresh Strawberries 4.95

Take Home Pie

10” Whole Pie

(Serves 6-10)    19.95

8” Whole Cream Pie

(Serves 4-6)  14.95

Whole Cake  Variety of choices

(Serves 4-6)   11.95  
(Serves 10-14)   25.00

Whole Cheesecake

(Serves 10-14)   29.95

Mom’s Homemade Sweet Rolls (4) - 10.95

Loaf of White or Wheat Bread - 3.75

Homemade Apple Butter (Pint) - 5.95

Homemade House Dressing (Pint) - 5.95

Newsletter Sign Up

To keep up with our village,
please enter your email address below: