Dessert Menu

Homemade Pies

7.95 per slice. À la mode add 2.00.

Our pies are baked fresh FROM SCRATCH every morning.
No meal at Yoder’s is ever complete without a piece of homemade pie.

Cream Pies

• Banana Cream
• Chocolate Cream
• Chocolate Peanut Butter
• Coconut Cream
• Florida Key Lime(Traditional in graham crust)
• Fresh Strawberry
• Homemade Butterscotch
• Peanut Butter Cream

Baked Pies

• Apple
• Blueberry
• Cherry
• Dutch Apple Crumb
• Pumpkin
• Southern Pecan
• Blackberry
• Black Raspberry
• Baked Peach
• Rhubarb
• Strawberry Rhubarb
• Mom’s Egg Custard
• Shoofly
• Sugar-free Apple

Cakes and More

• Homemade Cheesecake 7.95
• Yoder’s Best Chocolate Cake 7.50
• Cake of the Day 7.50
• Hand-dipped Ice Cream 4.95 with Fresh Strawberries 6.95
• Pie Flight - Sample your choice of three cream pie flavors - 10.50

Take Home Pie

10” Whole Pie

(Serves 6-10)    28.95

8” Whole Cream Pie

(Serves 4-6)  20.95

Whole Cake Variety of Choices

(Serves 4-6)   15.95  

Whole Cheesecake

(Serves 10-14)   34.95

Mom’s Homemade Sweet Rolls (1) - 6.95

Mom’s Homemade Sweet Rolls (4) - 15.95

Loaf of White or Wheat Bread - 3.95

Homemade Apple Butter (Pint) - 7.95

Homemade House Dressing (Pint) - 7.95